For the Hurricanes, one question always reigns supreme. With the bar set so high decades back, every new Miami team is chasing ghosts of yesteryear and while all the aforementioned inquiries apply to UM, when coming off a handful of down seasons, it always comes down to the same three words: “Is Miami back?” – with everyone knowing what “back” implies.
Year three of the Al Golden era and after over a half decade of mediocrity — 48-41 record, dating back to the 2005 Peach Bowl loss to LSU, to be exact — that heavy question seems to ring a little bit louder each passing year.
Miami is getting some love as another season is just over a month from kicking off. The Canes look to be ranked in the pre-season for only the second time since 2006 and finally have a few athletes making their way onto some awards lists, albeit all offensive players as that side of the ball appears loaded while the defense has much to prove.
The media has even changed its overall tune as of late, praising the recruiting efforts, a slew of recent verbal commitments, the talent Golden and staff will return this season (again, the praise coming on the offensive side of the ball) and the endurance the program has shown in light of the recent NCAA investigation, self-imposed bowl bans and some form of sanctions still looming, though a far cry from the ‘death penalty’ chatter that swelled two summers ago.
Year three is often the season a new coaches begins to make their mark, after taking over a program in some form of turmoil. For the better part of the past few decades, first-year Miami coaches were usually taking desirable jobs as their predecessors had moved on to professional riches, climbing the coaching ladder.
Jimmy Johnson took over for Howard Schnellenberger, who at the time took what looked to be a desirable coaching opportunity with the USFL in 1984. When Johnson left Miami for the Dallas Cowboys after the 1988 season, the cupboard was full for Dennis Erickson, who lasted six seasons with the Hurricanes before the Seattle Seahawks came calling.
Probation ensued for crimes committed on Erickson’s watch and while Butch Davis took over a prestigious program, probation and scholarship reductions put Miami in a bind, with the Hurricanes going 5-6 in Davis’ first year, after opening 8-3 and following up with a 9-3 campaign year two. (Miami self-imposed a bowl ban in 1995, Davis’ inaugural season as UM’s leader.)
Larry Coker also bucked the trend, taking over a loaded squad in 2001, going 24-1 out the gate and putting together an 11-2 campaign in his third season, which was followed by 9-3, 9-3 and 7-6, which led to his eventual firing after year six.
Randy Shannon took over a depleted squad in 2007, went 5-7 his first year, but signed a top-ranked recruiting class the following February. Miami went 7-6 in Shannon’s second season and year three boasted a 9-4 record, including early wins against Florida State, Georgia Tech and Oklahoma, but marred with regular season losses to Virginia Tech, Clemson and North Carolina, and eventually a bowl loss to Wisconsin.
Shannon stumbled year four, going 7-5 in the regular season, including a lopsided, 45-17 loss at home to Florida State, which was the beginning of the end – his team backsliding in what was expected to be a big-time season for Miami and a step forward. The number-one recruiting class from a few years back were juniors and instead of reaching that next level, most underachieved, never lived up to the hype and their game didn’t translate from the high school to college level.
While Shannon looked to have recruited strong in 2008, in hindsight it was a class with some marquee names, but not exceptionally solid regarding filling needs and voids. From there, the recruiting magic was lost and the next two classes proved to be the biggest detriment to early success for Golden and staff, outside of NCAA investigation itself.
Even the 2011 class, technically Golden’s signees though only on the job for two months when Signing Day approached, falls on Shannon’s shoulders as Miami only had four verbal commits in December 2010 when the coaching change took place. (Conversely, Miami already has twenty verbal commitments for the 2014 class in early July.)
Shannon’s 2009 class had nineteen signees and some names that looked good in theory, but didn’t pan out. Defensively Miami reeled in Shayon Green, Curtis Porter and Luther Robinson defensively, who are the only remaining veterans available this upcoming season.
Ray Ray Armstrong and Olivier Vernon were also members of this class, contributing little as one chased an NFL dream early, another was removed and both were at the heart of the Nevin Shapiro scandal, earning a total of eleven games suspended during the 2011 season.
Lamar Miller, Brandon McGee and Mike James were long-time contributors from the 2009 class who have since reached the NFL, and a handful more return this year –Dyron Dye, Jared Wheeler and AJ Highsmith, originally signed as a quarterback but moved to safety, but there were more busts than consistent and solid players.
Cory White. Stephen Plein. Jamal Reid. Billy Sanders. Prince Kent. Some who flamed out, others never played, and a few that didn’t qualify or got the boot.
When breaking down Miami’s current defensive woes and lack of depth, look no further than 2010 and 2011 as classes that will prove more crippling than probation, barring Golden navigates UM through any rough seas and the NCAA proves semi-fair with the punishment handed down (re: something in the three scholarships per year over three years arena).
Some of the names from 2010 that didn’t pan out; defensive tackle Jeffery Brown, defensive back Devont’a Davis, defensive tackle Tavadis Glenn, linebacker Kevin Nelson, defensive back Keion Payne, defensive end David Perry, defensive end Andrew Tallman, defensive tackle Delmar Taylor and linebacker Travis Williams. Late signee Latwan Anderson, projected as a defensive back, was also part of this class.
A year later, Golden’s thrown-together-last-minute class had some would-be athletes, but guys who battled immaturity and poor decision-making; defensive back Thomas Finnie, linebackers Eddie Johnson and Gionni Paul.
Defensive end Ricardo Williams proved to be a tweener and a bad overall fit, while cornerback/running back Kevin Grooms wound up at Marshall last minute and linebacker Antonio Kinard had academic issues and cornerback Dallas Crawford was eventually moved to running back.
Defensive end Jalen Grimble was also part of this class and while still on the squad, is yet to start and has only netted six career tackles.
Quick math will show that depending which side of the ball a few wound up on, up to nineteen would-be defenders didn’t pan out for the Hurricanes between 2010 and 2011, which is absolutely crippling and helps explain the defensive woes this program has endured during the first two years of the Golden era.
Even the drop-off Mark D’Onofrio and his defensive experienced between 2011 and 2012 were the result of so many players not panning out, as Miami was unable to endure the losses brought on by graduation, players who departed early and those not granted another year of eligibility.
Linebacker Sean Spence, safety JoJo Nicolas, defensive linemen Marcus Forston, Marcus Robinson, Adawale Ojomo, Micanor Regis and the aforementioned Vernon, should not have been impossible for Miami to overcome, but was based on the disastrous recruitment and development of players on the defensive side of the ball Shannon’s final two years and Golden’s first forced recruiting haul.
Taking all of this into consideration, it makes it rather difficult to answer the, “Is Miami back?” question regarding this upcoming season.
Will the defense be better? Absolutely. Why? Because honestly, it was so God-awful in 2012 that it really can’t be much worse – even with the losses of Finnie, Paul and Johnson, all due to being removed from the program (as was linebacker Gabe Terry from the 2012 class).
Depth remains an issue and with little change regarding the defensive line position, pressuring opposing quarterbacks will still be a problem and both an in-progress secondary and constantly shuffle linebacking core will be asked to work more miracles until the line starts winning those up front battles.
Miami will be an improved squad in 2013 and with a lighter out of conference schedule and an easier workload early on, opposed to taking on the likes of Florida State, Ohio State, Kansas State, Virginia Tech and Oklahoma out the gate as this program has over the past several seasons combined.
Florida does arrives week two, but the game is sandwiched between showdowns with Florida Atlantic and Savannah State, while games against Florida State and Virginia Tech take place early November, when Miami should’ve found it’s season groove – and if said groove has been been discovered, a case could be made that the Canes are “back”, but the result still may be inconclusive.
The old adage states that offense sells tickets, but defense wins championships and in a nutshells is the answer regarding Miami’s true return back to prominence. The Canes will be “back” when boasting a playmaking, aggressive defense that sets the tone, creates turnovers and makes statements week in and week out.
Look at every great Miami team over the years. Future NFL stars across the board. Disruptive defensive tackles, lockdown corners and heady, athletic linebackers who made sure the middle of the field was a war zone. The Canes don’t need a 2001 to 2003-era defense to be considered “back”, but certainly need something that churns out NFL talent, makes plays and sets tones. A far cry from one of the nation’s worst units, which was the case last season at The U, hard as that is to believe.
The talent is returning, though the defensive line remains thin – even looking at next year, unless some JUCO transfers can head south and have an immediate impact. Miami coaches are targeting top defensive line talent for the class of 2014, but with the dark cloud that’s hovered over this program the past few weeks, it’s been impossible to reel in Grade-A talent at that position for years now.
Many want to pin the lack of depth and overall defensive talent on coordinator Mark D’Onofrio, which is a logical knee-jerk reaction after watching points pile up last season, with the Canes unable to stop anyone.
Debating this point with those who feel that way is as much a waste of time as arguing religion or politics. Opinions are strong and one side isn’t going to sell the other on their belief system. Still, a few things to consider outside the lack of overall talent on the defensive side of the ball since The Golden Era began.
For starters, everything runs through Golden and entering last season, Miami’s then-second-year leader made it clear in the preseason that the Canes were going to have to outscore the competition as the defense simply wasn’t up to par.
Anyone wanting to debate that point, look no further than a 41-40 loss at Virginia where the loss of Johnson at linebacker (due to suspension) created a huge dropoff, while the secondary had three true freshmen in action as safety Deon Bush and cornerbacks Tracy Howard and Antonio Crawford were asked to hold it down, while the defensive line got zero penetration and the Cavaliers’ offense continued to answer the Canes’ potent attack.
Facing what truly “is” has proven the most difficult aspect of Miami’s decline for long-time fans. A consistent belief that the “U” on the helmet, the overall brand and the legacy can somehow instill fear and win ball games.
Fact is, the Canes’ success is still semi-recent as UM has been a college football staple for over thirty years, finding a way to dominate part, if not most, of each of the past three decades. Losing was foreign to Miami for so long and having watched this program rebound in the past, it always feels like the Canes are a player or two away from being back on top again.
One last time, that hasn’t been the case for almost a decade now. The decline started in 2003, progressed the next two years and bottomed out on Coker’s watch in 2006, with Miami’s worst season since shackled by probation in 1997.
The writing was on the wall, quality coaches wanted no part of rebuilding and Shannon was handed the keys, a logical choice as “keeping it in the family” made sense based on his success as a defensive coordinator.
The people skills lacked and the inexperience hurt, but if the first-time head coach could hire veteran assistants, learn on the job and maintain, maybe Miami had a shot a comeback.
Not quite.
A mess created on Coker’s watch got infinitely worse under Shannon and by the time Golden took over, UM was a shell of the program Davis left behind almost a decade earlier. There would be no quick fix and Miami wasn’t a few players away from anything redeemable.
Even worse, the culture was dead. The work ethic nowhere near what it was when the greats battled it out at Greentree. The wrong players had settled in, as did a sense of entitlement and lethargy. The Canes were poorly conditioned and the win-loss record proved it, as did the way Miami was losing.
Offensively, a Duke Johnson can take a handoff and make an immediate impact as Golden inherited a squad that had a good enough offensive line, a quality quarterback in Stephen Morris and a few raw receivers who came around, as there was depth at that position. Defense? A completely different monster all together.
Without turning this into a full-blown defensive breakdown and D’Onofrio-fueled debate, it’s better to agree to disagree for one more season and close with this; if the current coordinator is good enough for the man in charge, he deserves the benefit of the doubt for one more season, minimum.
Fans cannot be sold on all things Golden, yet in the next breath question his choice in D’Onofrio. Golden has a blueprint, process and game plan to get Miami back and in just about every phase it’s currently proving successful. He stuck it out through probation, he knows this is a career job and also knows this is a tough, unforgiving city.
In other words, Golden knows that defense is what makes Miami tick and that until that side of the ball is humming again, he needs to overcompensate in other areas in effort to win, while recruiting like a madman and bringing in more ass-kickers on that side of the ball.
Golden’s career depends on the success of this program and the best way to win games is to keep the other guys from scoring. Golden’s success is dependent on figuring this out and he has chosen to vouch for his friend, former teammate and long-time coaching partner – a guy who was given little work with years one and two.
Year three is here and after reaching rock bottom last year, there’s nowhere to go but up. Can Golden and D’Onofrio get the most out of what they’re working with? Will experience and maturity come as a result from so many newbies being thrown to the wolves last year, battle-tested right out the gate? Even the biggest skeptic would have to say ‘yes’.
Year one started with Shapiro-fueled suspensions while the second season dealt with a hovering NCAA cloud, as well as key departures of veterans with no capable, experienced replacements. Again, things that the frustrated will call “excuses” while the logically-minded can accept as “explanations”.
Pivotal year ahead and one where a more consistent, veteran offense will have to set the tone, while the defense takes some necessary steps forward, without falling apart as it did in 2012.
Is Miami back? In a word, no – not yet. But 2013 will field the best overall unit this program has seen is years, made up of the right kind of players as the harsh pruning process weeded out the dead weight.
An exciting year is on the horizon and a stage-setting situation that will soon remind the rest of the college football world that another Miami rebirth is just around the corner.
Already looking forward to that “back” question again next summer.
Christian Bello has been covering Miami Hurricanes athletics since the mid-1990s. After spending almost a decade as a columnist for CanesTime, he launched allCanesBlog.com. – the official blog for allCanes.com : The #1 Canes Shop Since 1959. Bello has joined up with XOFan.com and will be a guest columnist at CaneInsider.com this fall. Follow him on Twitter @ChristianRBello.
comments
The constant re-litigating of the winning-cures-all-while-losing-exposes-warts sentiment rolls on as Miami faithful continue flailing in…
Josh Pate gets it... and I'm not just saying that because he dedicated an entire…
Tyler Van Dyke may very well have thrown his last meaningful pass for the Miami…
We can debate the merits of winning-curing-all and losses-killing-perspective at another time. For now, focus…
Winning might not cure everything, but it certainly can shift a narrative overnight—immediately lightening…
The only remedy for a gut-wrenching loss to Georgia Tech would've been the Miami Hurricanes…
View Comments
It's time for Golden to finally start making moves. You give alot of excuses and reasons for why this has taken so long, yet a team like Kansas State was able to turn it around in 2 years to a top 5 team and in each of the "first two years" of Snyder part 2 there was noticeable improvement. Jimbo Fisher made a dramatic difference and FSU turned around significantly after Bowden had them swimming in mediocrity over an extensive number of years.
I'll buy the argument that looming sanctions and threats hindered us to compete with FSU as we may have been able to win some of those recruiting battles if we didnt have "one arm tied behind out back" but K'States lack of history and talent pool should be a wash with our handicapped recuriting efforts.
My point is while Coker and Shannon did terrible jobs, it doesn't always take 5 years to rebuild a program. This is year 3. Years when coaches like Snyder and Jimbo took bad to average teams to contending heights. Excuses and blame on the past is over. The time for 9-10 wins and national contention should be starting.
Jason - Kansas State proved to be a perfect storm of upperclassmen coming together at the right time. Would venture to say the Wildcats are back to 7-5 or 8-4 next season now that their Cinderella run with a Heisman-worthy quarterback has moved on. Happened to have a few upperclassmen offensive and defensive players who made a difference, but are now gone - proving the Wildcats aren't a power program, just a middle of the road Big XII team where things game together for a nice run.
A similar thing happened to Auburn the year they won a title with Cam Newton at the helm. 8-5 the next year and 3-9 after that, which got Gene Chizik fired.
Florida State is a bad example, too. Yes, Fisher made them better - but again, he was working with a TON more talent. Bowden and staff were still recruiting well and had depth and talent on both sides of the ball. The "clean up" Fisher had to deal with at FSU was nothing compared to what Golden walked into at UM.
Again, Snyder and Kansas State didn't build, or rebuild a program. They had two good seasons because the stars aligned. As for Florida State, Fisher is proving to have a little more fire than Bowden and is winning a few more games a year. Two years in a row Florida State earned a top five preseason rank and what'd they do with it? 9-4 in 2011 and 12-2 last year with lackluster wins over Georgia Tech for an ACC Title and beat Northern Illinois in the Orange Bowl?
How is that a "dramatic" difference at Florida State? 9-4, 10-4 and finally 12-2 last year? Bowden even went 9-4 in 2008 and Fisher took over in 2010. Those three 7-6 seasons Bowden put together were underachieving, not a lack of talent. That program wasn't a mess. It simply needed a new head coach.
Based on talent and preseason rank the past few years, for Florida State to go 9-4 - with some embarrassing losses? To go 12-2 last year with that season-defining, title-dream-ending loss to North Carolina State? Please. Miami fans would have a head coach's head on a stick if that happened with a top five team that was in the title hunt.
Miami was in decline since 2003. Golden took over for the 2011 season. That's EIGHT bad seasons and Al's first year was met with suspensions, NCAA issues and nothing has let up -- all of which led to negative recruiting and because of a broken culture, a real hit to the depth chart as the staff cut ties with a lot of players that didn't fit the process.
You're entitled to your opinion, but in regards to your argument, it really is flawed logic. Kansas State will prove to be a two-year wonder. Bank that they fall WAY off without Brown, Klein, Tannahill, Pease, Tuggle, etc. Lest not forget this is Snyder's second stint with KSU, going back to coaching in 2009 after stepping down after 2005. His final two years in Manhattan before stepping down in 2005 -- 4-7 and 5-6. Came back in 2009 and went 6-6 and 7-6 before the past two years. (Is also 1-5 in his past six bowl games.)
Lastly, you say it shouldn't take five years to rebuild. Golden is entering year three and this should be a step forward. Coming off of 7-5, getting to a 9- or 10-win season should be doable, so again, where are the "excuses"? Talking about HOW this got where it is, HOW it's trying to get out, WHAT it will take and setting realistic expectations with a new season upon us.
I really wonder about our fan base sometimes. Not trying to be antagonistic, but CANESNYC is so far off base it's frightening. Even a college football novice could see that Kansas State was a fluke the past two years and it was all about Collin Klein, a veteran defense, a few toughnosed runningbacks and huge receivers. Agree with the site mod here. The Wildcats might be a 6-6 team next year. Bill Snyder didn't build a program. He reaped the benefits of things coming together with recruiting and having a lot of upperclassmen on a veteran team.
And regarding Florida State and Dumbo Fisher, he has so much more talent at his disposal the past few years its scary. The Noles just sent eleven players to the NFL a few months ago. Three first rounders and two second rounders and guys recruited when Coach Bowden was still in charge up there so again backing what the mod here said, that program was nowhere near the dumpster fire that THE U was when Al took over. It's not even close, friend.
I have followed this Miami program since the Charlie Tate era and was going to the Orange Bowl when games were on Friday nights, not Saturdays. What Mr. Golden was handed and what he's expected to do is nothing short of a miracle in this day and age for a private university that has no state funding and hasn't been able to compete in regards to facilities. I see now that some changes are being made, but it still is nothing in comparison to changes that have been made at other larger state schools with endless streams of money and boosters who write blank checks. In Miami the only booster that ever gave big money to this program is a Ponzi schemer and is in jail after ratting out the program he supposedly loved.
Al Golden is two years into fixing problems that date back to Miami's last Bowl Championship Series appearance after the 2003 season. If you know anything about sports, which is a lot like business, cleaning up the messes of past employees is a very tedious process. Give Al a fair shake and let's see what is done this year with that defense which was horrible last year but will be much better this year.
Great write-up, Chris. I think we can and will take another step forward this year. The offense will have to outscore people until the D Line comes into shape. You can have Ed Reed and Ray lewis back there and until the line steps up, it doesn't really matter if the big guys don't start making plays. We have a friendlier overall schedule this year on top of that. I trust Golden's plan and have been impressed with how his 2014 recruiting class is shaping up. Imagine what he will do once the damn NCAA harrassment ends. To me, this is a really important year and The U will open eyes. I'm calling a win over the Gators here and now, even with the defense in transition. One month to go!!!
John - The season will definitely be dictated by the offense, especially in the sense that it will take pressure off the defense. And like you said, the easier start, minus the Florida game, will allow guys to ease in and momentum to build.
There is no reason that year three for Golden's squad can't result in a 9-3 or 10-2 season, easily, as well as a trip to the ACC Championship game.
I also agree that a win over Florida is very doable. Miami coaches need to look at the blueprint Louisville's offense brought against them in the Sugar Bowl. For all that talk about the Gators' defense, they got carved up pretty good that night.
If Miami's offense can solve Florida's defense, a very, very winnable game for the Canes. The Gators' offense doesn't scare anyone - even a struggling Canes' defense that will be improved this season.
They will score a lot. Curtis Porter is a beast when healthy. Need a DT or two to step up or D will not improve much. LBs and secondary should be better but they need a pass rush. Chick needs to play as billed and transfer from Wisc. is also a beast but health is an issue. In short, the D has a lot of ifs because of a lack of depth but should improve enough for a 10-win season. When the NCAA is out the way then Golden can work on DT depth. With that they can truly get "back".
Agree, Mike. If healthy, Porter will be a big help and with more support there, we'll see more production out of Chick - who needed to workout and beef up this past off-season, which he did.
Defense will be more experienced and improved, which is the lone benefit of playing so many young guys last year.
Offense will be better and more consistent - a la, no late starts, slumps or late rallies, as well as 3- or 14-point outings. Canes need to put up between 21 and 42 a game, depending on the opponent and it's doable with a consistent offense. Last year was Morris' first year under center as starter. This senior season should be a brilliant one.
I agree totally with your article. The D-Line is the weakness. The best DT we have had since 2005 was Allen Bailey. Which is sad because he was really and truly suppossed to be a DE.
But I still preach that the Defensive Staff should coach to their strengths, I can bear another game where we cant get off the field on 3rd down.
That was the most intelligent and insightful rebuttal to all the blinded Cane "fans" who question Al Golden's process! You couldn't have written that response (and article) any better! This needs to be displayed across all Cane boards and forums so these Cane "fans" can realize what a train wreck Golden and company walked into! He didn't take over a Miami program of the past. When he took over, it was in the worst shape, besides the Butch Davis era, it had been in since the Howard days! You're always a great read and keep up the good work! Go Canes!
Thanks for the kind words and feel free to share away! This piece was written by a fan for the fans and this blog certainly isn't stale or corporate. We write what we write because we care about this program! - CB